Google Cloud vs AWS: A comprehensive comparison for business users
By Max Ikaheimo
January 5th, 2024
As the sun rises on a new era of digital transformation, it’s not a surprise that a striking 94% of enterprises have already set sail on their cloud computing journeys leveraging the possibilities offered by providers like Amazon Web Services (AWS) and Google Cloud Platform (GCP).
This overwhelming shift to the cloud is more than a mere trend; it's a paradigm shift, fundamentally altering the technological landscape and offering businesses a new horizon of scalability, innovation, and efficiency.
In this post, we'll dive into the unique aspects of AWS and GCP, unraveling how each platform can be a compass guiding businesses to their desired digital destinations.
Table of contents
- In this post:
The cloud giants: GCP and AWS
Google Cloud and Amazon Web Service have emerged as leading players in the cloud industry. While AWS has been a pioneer, offering a wide range of services like Amazon EC2 and Amazon S3, Google Cloud has been catching up with its innovative offerings like Google Compute Engine and Google Cloud Storage.
Amazon Web Services (AWS)
Brief history:
Launch: AWS was officially launched in 2006, making it one of the pioneers in the cloud computing space. It started with the release of its two core services, Amazon S3 (Simple Storage Service) and Amazon EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud).
Evolution: Over the years, AWS expanded its service offerings significantly, introducing various new services and features, including AWS Lambda for serverless computing and Amazon RDS for relational databases.
Growth: AWS has grown exponentially, becoming the backbone for many companies, ranging from startups to large enterprises. It played a crucial role in popularizing the cloud computing model.
Market share and industry presence:
Market leader: As of 2023, AWS held the largest share of the cloud computing market, significantly ahead of its competitors.
Diverse clientele: AWS's clientele includes major corporations, government agencies, and educational institutions. It's known for its broad service offering, high reliability, and extensive global infrastructure.
Industry impact: AWS has had a profound impact on the IT industry, driving the shift towards cloud computing and influencing how companies build and deploy applications.
Google Cloud Platform (GCP)
Brief history:
Launch: Google Cloud was officially launched in 2008, initially focusing on App Engine, a platform for developing and hosting web applications in Google-managed data centers.
Expansion: Google Cloud expanded its services to include Google Compute Engine in 2012, offering virtual machines, and later adding storage and database services.
Strategic shifts: Over the years, Google Cloud has made strategic shifts to focus more on enterprise customers, offering solutions in data analytics, machine learning, and open-source technologies.
Market Share and Industry Presence:
Growing competitor: While Google Cloud holds a smaller portion of the market compared to AWS, it has been rapidly gaining traction, especially among technology-focused companies and industries leveraging big data and AI.
Innovative solutions: Known for its cutting-edge solutions in data analytics, machine learning, and containerization with Kubernetes.
Client base: Google Cloud's client base includes large enterprises that prioritize data analytics and machine learning, as well as startups and SMBs looking for scalable and innovative cloud solutions.
Industry adoption and expert opinions: AWS vs Google Cloud
While both platforms are similar, very similar in fact - there are some differences for industry adoption and more specifically which sectors prefer one over the other.
Industries predominantly using AWS:
Technology and startups: AWS is popular among tech companies and startups for its extensive range of services and scalability. Companies like Netflix and Airbnb use AWS for their robust computing needs.
Government and public sector: AWS has a strong presence in government sectors, offering specific solutions that comply with government security and compliance standards.
Healthcare: Leveraging its compliance with healthcare regulations (like HIPAA), AWS is widely used in the healthcare industry for managing patient data and healthcare applications.
Finance and banking: Financial institutions favor AWS for its security features and comprehensive compliance with financial regulations.
Expert opinions on AWS
Experts often cite AWS's maturity, extensive service offerings, and strong enterprise focus as key advantages. Forecasts suggest continued growth, especially in sectors like government and healthcare, driven by AWS's focus on compliance and security.
Google Cloud industry adoption
Data analytics and machine learning: Companies focusing on big data, analytics, and machine learning prefer Google Cloud for its strength in these areas, exemplified by services like BigQuery and TensorFlow.
Retail: To avoid competition with Amazon, some retail companies choose Google Cloud. Google's advanced analytics and AI/ML capabilities are also a draw.
Gaming and entertainment: Google Cloud is popular in the gaming industry for its data analytics and global network capabilities, which are crucial for online gaming platforms.
Manufacturing and industrial: Leveraging Google Cloud’s IoT and AI/ML capabilities, manufacturing industries use it for predictive maintenance, supply chain optimization, and other advanced applications.
Expert opinions on Google Cloud
Experts recognize Google Cloud as a leader in data analytics and artificial intelligence, often highlighting its innovative approach and integration with Google’s AI capabilities.
Future forecasts for Google Cloud suggest a growing market share, particularly in industries where analytics and machine learning are key.
Core services: A comparative look
Both platforms offer a variety of services, but they excel in different areas. AWS’s Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2) and Simple Storage Service (S3) are industry benchmarks for virtual machines and storage services.
In contrast, GCP’s Compute Engine and Cloud Storage offer high performance and flexibility, especially for big data and data science applications.
| Feature | AWS | GCP |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing structure | Pay-as-you-go model. Complex pricing with various options and add-ons. | Straightforward pricing. Discounts for sustained use and pre-emptible instances. |
| Cost predictability | Less predictable due to variable pricing models. Offers AWS Pricing Calculator. | More predictable with sustained use discounts. Google Cloud Pricing Calculator for estimates. |
| Free tier | Offers a 12-month free tier with limited access to services. Includes AWS Lambda, Amazon S3, and EC2 instances. | Offers a 12-month free tier with $300 credit to use any Google Cloud product. Always Free products like Google App Engine and Google Compute Engine. |
| Long-term commitments | Offers Reserved Instances for 1 to 3 years with significant discounts. | Committed Use Discounts for 1 to 3 years, providing lower costs compared to on-demand pricing. |
| Scalability costs | Can be expensive for scaling due to its pricing model. Suitable for large-scale operations with complex requirements. | Generally more cost-effective for scaling. Ideal for startups and businesses with variable workloads. |
| Budget management tools | AWS Budgets for tracking usage and costs. AWS Cost Explorer for analyzing and managing AWS spend. | Google Cloud Billing Reports. Cost Management tools for monitoring and optimizing expenses. |
| Discounts for startups | AWS Activate offers credits, training, and support for startups. | Google Cloud for Startups provides cloud credits, training, and technical support. |
| Billing increments | Charges per second for EC2 and per minute for other services. | Charges per second for all computing services. |
| Data transfer costs | Charges for data transfer exceed certain limits. Cost varies by region and service. | Competitive data transfer rates. Egress traffic costs can be lower compared to AWS. |
| Custom pricing options | Available for businesses with high usage or unique requirements. | Custom pricing available for high-volume projects and enterprise needs. |
Pricing models: What suits startups best?
Pricing is a critical factor for startups. AWS offers a pay-as-you-go model, but can be complex with its various pricing options.
GCP, on the other hand, provides a more straightforward and often more cost-effective pricing structure, especially for compute-intensive tasks.
| Feature | AWS | GCP |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing structure | Pay-as-you-go model. Complex pricing with various options and add-ons. | Straightforward pricing. Discounts for sustained use and pre-emptible instances. |
| Cost predictability | Less predictable due to variable pricing models. Offers AWS Pricing Calculator. | More predictable with sustained use discounts. Google Cloud Pricing Calculator for estimates. |
| Free tier | Offers a 12-month free tier with limited access to services. Includes AWS Lambda, Amazon S3, and EC2 instances. | Offers a 12-month free tier with $300 credit to use any Google Cloud product. Always Free products like Google App Engine and Google Compute Engine. |
| Long-term commitments | Offers Reserved Instances for 1 to 3 years with significant discounts. | Committed Use Discounts for 1 to 3 years, providing lower costs compared to on-demand pricing. |
| Scalability costs | Can be expensive for scaling due to its pricing model. Suitable for large-scale operations with complex requirements. | Generally more cost-effective for scaling. Ideal for startups and businesses with variable workloads. |
| Budget management tools | AWS Budgets for tracking usage and costs. AWS Cost Explorer for analyzing and managing AWS spend. | Google Cloud Billing Reports. Cost Management tools for monitoring and optimizing expenses. |
| Discounts for startups | AWS Activate offers credits, training, and support for startups. | Google Cloud for Startups provides cloud credits, training, and technical support. |
| Billing increments | Charges per second for EC2 and per minute for other services. | Charges per second for all computing services. |
| Data transfer costs | Charges for data transfer exceed certain limits. Cost varies by region and service. | Competitive data transfer rates. Egress traffic costs can be lower compared to AWS. |
| Custom pricing options | Available for businesses with high usage or unique requirements. | Custom pricing available for high-volume projects and enterprise needs. |
Performance and scalability
Both AWS and GCP provide scalable solutions, but AWS leads in terms of global reach with more availability zones and data centers.
However, GCP is known for its high-performance computing engine, making it a strong contender for compute-heavy applications.
| Feature | AWS | GCP |
|---|---|---|
| Overall performance | Wide range of instance types for various workloads. Optimized for compute-intensive, memory-intensive, and storage-intensive tasks. Strong global network for low-latency and high throughput. | High-performance virtual machines with live migration feature. Global fiber network for high throughput and low latency. Custom and optimized VMs for specific tasks. |
| Scalability features | Auto Scaling for automatic capacity adjustment. Elastic Load Balancing for traffic distribution. Scalable storage with Amazon S3 and EBS. | Automatic scaling with Compute Engine. Global load balancing for reduced latency. Automatically scalable Google Cloud Storage with various classes. |
| Load balancing | Advanced load balancing capabilities across multiple targets. Suitable for large-scale and complex applications. | Efficient global load balancing, distributing requests to nearest data centers. Ideal for reducing latency and improving user experience. |
| Storage scalability | Highly scalable storage solutions with S3 and EBS. Suitable for a wide range of storage needs and applications. | Flexible and scalable storage options. Offers various storage classes for different performance and cost requirements. |
| Network performance | Extensive global infrastructure ensures high performance. Low-latency network suitable for global applications. | High throughput and low latency due to global fiber network. Ideal for data-intensive applications. |
| Instance optimization | Instances tailored for specific types of tasks. Broad selection catering to diverse needs. | Custom VM creation for specific needs. Compute-optimized, memory-optimized instances available. |
| Cost-effectiveness in scaling | Scalability can be cost-effective but requires careful planning. Suitable for businesses with variable workloads. | Generally more cost-effective in scaling. Efficient for startups and businesses with fluctuating demands. |
Security and compliance
Security is paramount in cloud services. AWS and GCP both offer robust cloud security features and compliance with various standards.
AWS’s access management and security tools are highly mature, while GCP offers innovative security features, especially for hybrid cloud environments.
| Feature | AWS | GCP |
|---|---|---|
| Security features | Advanced security features including AWS Shield for DDoS protection, AWS WAF for web application firewall, and AWS IAM for access control. | Strong security tools like Google Cloud Armor for DDoS protection, Cloud Identity & Access Management (IAM) for managing access, and Data Loss Prevention API. |
| Compliance certifications | Extensive range of compliance certifications including HIPAA, GDPR, FedRAMP, and ISO. | Broad set of compliance offerings including GDPR, HIPAA, ISO, and FedRAMP, similar to AWS. |
| Data encryption | Offers encryption at rest and in transit. AWS Key Management Service (KMS) and AWS CloudHSM provide key storage and management. | Encryption at rest and in transit as standard. Cloud Key Management Service and Cloud HSM for key management and security. |
| Identity and access management | AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM) allows granular control over users and permissions. | Google Cloud Identity & Access Management (IAM) offers detailed access control and integration with Google Workspace. |
| Network security | Virtual Private Cloud (VPC) for network isolation, Security Groups, and Network ACLs for inbound and outbound filtering. | Google Cloud VPC provides network isolation, and Cloud Firewall offers robust network security and rules management. |
| Threat detection and response | AWS GuardDuty for threat detection and AWS Inspector for security assessment. | Google Cloud Security Command Center for threat and data risk management, and Event Threat Detection. |
| Privacy controls | Comprehensive privacy controls, including data residency options and tools for managing data access. | Strong privacy controls with tools for data governance and transparency, including data residency options. |
| Security best practices and guidance | Extensive documentation and best practices for securing AWS environments. AWS Well-Architected Framework for security guidance. | Detailed documentation and best practices for security on GCP. Google Cloud’s security whitepapers and architecture framework. |
| Managed security services | AWS offers managed security services like Amazon Macie for data security and privacy. | GCP provides managed security services such as Security Command Center and Cloud Armor. |
| Hybrid and multi-cloud security | AWS supports hybrid cloud environments with services like AWS Outposts. Offers security solutions tailored for multi-cloud environments. | Anthos for hybrid and multi-cloud management with integrated security controls. GCP’s approach to security extends to multi-cloud environments. |
User experience and support
For startups, ease of use is essential. GCP’s interface is often considered more user-friendly, and its integration with other Google services like Google Workspace and Google Search can be advantageous.
AWS, with its extensive service offerings, can be overwhelming but provides comprehensive documentation and community support.
| Feature | AWS | GCP |
|---|---|---|
| User interface | AWS Management Console offers a comprehensive but complex interface. Requires a learning curve due to the breadth of services. | Google Cloud Console is known for its user-friendly and intuitive interface. Easier for beginners and integrates well with other Google services. |
| Documentation and resources | Extensive documentation, tutorials, and community forums. AWS also offers a wide range of training and certification programs. | Comprehensive documentation, quickstart guides, and community support. GCP also provides various training courses and certifications. |
| Customer support | Offers various levels of support plans, including Basic, Developer, Business, and Enterprise. Known for its professional and responsive support. | Provides support plans like Basic (free), Role-Based Support, and Premium Support. Generally receives positive feedback for support quality. |
| Developer tools and integration | Rich set of developer tools including AWS CLI, SDKs, and IDE integrations. Strong ecosystem for DevOps and CI/CD workflows. | Strong set of developer tools with easy integration into popular IDEs. Google Cloud’s tools are particularly optimized for data and AI/ML projects. |
| Community and forums | Large and active user community. Numerous forums, discussion groups, and third-party resources available. | Growing community with active participation in forums and online platforms. Strong presence in open-source communities. |
| Ease of deployment and management | AWS offers services like AWS Elastic Beanstalk for easy deployment and AWS CloudFormation for infrastructure management. | GCP provides Google App Engine for straightforward application deployment and Cloud Deployment Manager for managing cloud resources. |
| Marketplace and third-party tools | AWS Marketplace offers a vast range of third-party tools and integrations. | Google Cloud Marketplace provides a wide selection of third-party solutions and integrations. |
| Innovation and updates | Regular updates and new features added frequently. AWS is known for its rapid innovation cycle. | Consistently introduces new features and improvements. GCP is recognized for its focus on cutting-edge technologies like AI and machine learning. |
| Customization and flexibility | High level of customization options for services. Suitable for complex and large-scale enterprise needs. | Offers significant customization and flexibility, especially attractive for developers working on innovative and emerging technologies. |
| Training and learning resources | AWS Training and Certification programs are well-regarded in the industry. Offers extensive resources for learning and upskilling. | Google Cloud offers training programs and certifications, with a focus on cloud technologies, data, and AI/ML. |
Unique Features
Both AWS and GCP have unique features and services. While it's generally possible to achieve the same things with both platforms, some platform specific features might be a better fit for certain situations. Let's take a quick look.
Amazon Web Services (AWS)
AWS Lambda: Pioneering serverless computing platform allowing users to run code without provisioning or managing servers.
Amazon S3 Glacier: Extremely low-cost storage service for data archiving and long-term backup with reliable and secure data storage infrastructure.
AWS Outposts: Brings native AWS services, infrastructure, and operating models to virtually any data center, co-location space, or on-premises facility.
Amazon Aurora: High performance managed relational database compatible with MySQL and PostgreSQL that combines the speed and availability of high-end commercial databases with the simplicity and cost-effectiveness of open source databases.
AWS Marketplace: A digital catalog with thousands of software listings from independent software vendors that make it easy to find, test, buy, and deploy software that runs on AWS.
Google Cloud Platform (GCP)
Google BigQuery: Fully-managed, serverless data warehouse that enables scalable analysis over petabytes of data. It is a powerful Big Data analytics platform used by all sizes of businesses.
Google Kubernetes Engine (GKE): A managed environment for deploying, managing, and scaling containerized applications using Google infrastructure.
Google App Engine: A fully managed, serverless platform for developing and hosting web applications at scale. It automatically scales applications up and down while balancing the load.
Google Cloud Bigtable: A fully managed, scalable NoSQL database service for large analytical and operational workloads. It's designed for high throughput and low latency.
Network Intelligence Center: Provides comprehensive network monitoring, verification, and optimization on Google Cloud's global networking infrastructure.
Cloud migration and integration
Cloud migration is a critical aspect for businesses moving to the cloud. AWS provides a mature environment with a wide range of tools and services for seamless migration. GCP, with its Cloud SQL and Big Data services, offers efficient solutions for data-heavy migrations.
| Feature | AWS | GCP |
|---|---|---|
| Cloud migration services | AWS offers a suite of tools like AWS Migration Hub, AWS Database Migration Service, and AWS Server Migration Service for seamless migration. | GCP provides services like Cloud Migration, Transfer Service, and Database Migration Service for efficient data transfer and migration. |
| Integration capabilities | Strong integration with a wide range of AWS services and third-party applications. Offers AWS Direct Connect for dedicated network connections. | Offers seamless integration with Google services and third-party applications. Cloud Interconnect provides direct connectivity to Google's network. |
| Data transfer and synchronization | AWS DataSync for automated and accelerated data transfer. AWS Storage Gateway integrates on-premises IT environments with cloud-based storage. | Cloud Storage Transfer Service for online data transfer. Cloud Filestore for integrated file storage and sharing capabilities. |
| Hybrid cloud support | AWS Outposts offers AWS infrastructure and services on-premises for a truly consistent hybrid experience. | Anthos allows for consistent deployment, management, and scaling of applications across cloud and on-premises environments. |
| Migration for specific workloads | Specialized solutions for migrating various workloads, including websites, databases, and enterprise applications. | Tailored approaches for migrating specific types of workloads, such as VMs, databases, and applications. |
| Migration tools and resources | Comprehensive set of tools and documentation for planning and executing migrations. AWS also offers training and support for migration projects. | Extensive resources including documentation, best practices, and tools for migration planning and execution. GCP also provides training and support. |
| Managed services for migration | AWS Managed Services provides an automated and secure cloud environment, simplifying the migration process. | Managed services like Google Cloud Managed Services offer support for migration, reducing complexity and ensuring a smooth transition. |
| Post-migration optimization | Tools like AWS Cost Explorer and AWS Trusted Advisor for optimizing costs and performance post-migration. | Offers tools like Google Cloud’s operations suite for monitoring, logging, and optimizing cloud resources after migration. |
| Partner ecosystem | Extensive network of AWS Partner Network (APN) members offering specialized migration services and solutions. | Strong partner network with expertise in GCP migrations, providing additional support and specialized services. |
| Application modernization | Services like AWS Elastic Beanstalk and AWS Lambda for modernizing applications during or after migration. | Offers Google Kubernetes Engine and Cloud Functions for modernizing applications and adopting cloud-native technologies. |
Conclusion
Looking beyond basic storage service and compute engine, both AWS and GCP are continuously evolving. AWS leads in market share and enterprise adoption, but GCP is making significant strides, particularly in areas like machine learning, artificial intelligence, and containerization with its Google Kubernetes Engine.
Choosing between Google Cloud Platform and Amazon Web Services depends on specific business needs, budget constraints, and technical requirements.
While AWS offers a more extensive range of services and a broader global infrastructure, GCP provides high-performance computing and is more cost-effective for certain use cases.
For startups and businesses, the decision should align with their long-term technological strategy and growth plans.
Contact us
Get in touch and let's discuss your business case
Submitting this form will not sign you up for any marketing lists. Your information is strictly used and stored for contacting you. Privacy Policy
Related posts: